MUMBAI: Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT) Friday unanimously approved a Rs 50-crore grant to the charitable trust that runs Pune’s Jehangir Hospital, but only after trustees discussed whether the funding presented a potential conflict of interest as hospital chairman Jehangir H C Jehangir is one of only 3 permanent trustees of closely linked Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT). The other two are Tatas, Jimmy and Noel.People familiar with the deliberations said questions were raised over whether Jehangir Hospital met the trust’s grant criteria and whether Jehangir’s position at SRTT made the beneficiary a related party. Trustees were told the hospital is run by Cawasji Jehangir Charitable Trust, rather than as a profit-making corporate hospital.Surplus generated by the hospital is ploughed back into the institution and does not accrue to Jehangir personally, those familiar with the developments said. The concerns prompted a discussion and a presentation on the hospital and its structure. A Rs 300-crore expansion plan was outlined, including construction of an additional building, towards which SDTT is providing support.The approval included support from Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh, whose positions on the proposal had been unclear. The Noel Tata-chaired SDTT also has Bhaskar Bhat and Noel’s son Neville Tata as trustees.The Rs 50-crore grant was among five proposals approved by SDTT on Friday. In all, the trust approved grants of Rs 150 crore to Rs 200 crore. Jehangir’s position at SRTT has assumed greater significance amid divisions within Tata Trusts over the future of Tata Sons. SDTT and SRTT hold about 28% and 24% of Tata Sons, respectively, and share some trustees. Srinivasan, who also sits on SRTT, and Singh, whose term there recently ended, have clashed with Noel, a permanent trustee of SRTT, on governance issues.Noel’s older half-brother Jimmy Tata, also a permanent trustee of SRTT, has opposed him on key issues. Jehangir has, in contrast, made no public statement on the governance disputes, although he had voted against Singh’s continuation on the Tata Sons board. Despite that, Singh backed the Rs 50-crore grant.











